How to Judge an Online Auction: Not Views, but Bids, Participants, Sell-Through and Sold Prices
When you are choosing an auction company, ask what happened in its completed auctions. How many people actually bid? How much bidding did each lot attract? What percentage sold, and at what prices?
Watchlisters show interest. Bids drive prices. Sold results tell the story.
Even a busy open house can make the audience look larger than the pool of potential buyers: one household may arrive with spouses and kids, while curious passersby stop in for a look. Twenty visitors do not necessarily mean twenty potential buyers.
Auction views deserve the same scrutiny. A view count can overstate distinct buyer interest: repeat visits may be counted separately, and some visitors are simply browsing. Like open-house attendance, the total alone does not tell you how many people are ready to make an offer.
That is why online auction sellers should look at watchlisters, unique bidders and bids per lot, then check how that activity translates into final sold prices and the percentage of lots sold.
Below are a cross section of BidRush auctions. Each example shows bidding activity, participation and final sale results, with a link to the auction.
Four numbers to ask for before you choose an auction company
- Bids per lot: Total bids divided by all eligible lots offered, including unsold lots. Read this alongside unique bidders: one person can place several bids, and bidding systems and increments affect the count.
- Participants: Unique people who bid, watchlisted, or did both. Bidders demonstrate willingness to buy; watchlisters express interest. Someone who does both is counted once in the participant total.
- Sell-through: The percentage of offered lots that sold. If you need to clear a property, also ask how many lots remained unsold and whether purchased items were collected.
- Final sold prices: Look at comparable items, average sold-lot price and total auction sales. A standout result is useful context, but the mix and condition of items matter.
Ontario: 500+ lots sold in Caledonia, with results across five communities
Start with Caledonia, where more than 500 lots sold. Then look across Windsor, Collingwood, Burlington and Mississauga for examples of local participation at different auction sizes.
Caledonia
For a seller clearing an estate, the number of lots sold matters. In Caledonia, 505 of 520 offered lots sold, supported by 4,969 bids. That is 97.1% sell-through across a substantial auction, with 216 people bidding, watchlisting, or doing both.
- 505 of 520 lots sold · 97.1% sell-through
- 4,969 bids · 9.6 bids per lot
- 216 participants · 94 unique bidders · 170 unique watchlisters
- Total final bids: CAD $13,139.05
- Average sold-lot price: CAD $26.02
Sold for CAD $541 on BidRush
14K Gold Chain Bracelet — Caledonia, Ontario
Windsor
Windsor provides an example on a smaller scale: all 54 lots sold. The auction attracted 59 unique bidders and averaged 13.1 bids per lot, with an Omega Speedmaster leading the final prices.
- 54 of 54 lots sold · 100% sell-through
- 710 bids · 13.1 bids per lot
- 85 participants · 59 unique bidders · 49 unique watchlisters
- Total final bids: CAD $10,829.00
- Average sold-lot price: CAD $200.54
Sold for CAD $4,550 on BidRush
Omega Speedmaster Professional Wristwatch with Presentation Box — Windsor, Ontario
Collingwood
Collingwood combines complete sell-through with 17.2 bids per lot. Its highest-priced lot was a sectional sofa—a useful reminder to look at results for the kinds of items you plan to sell.
- 116 of 116 lots sold · 100% sell-through
- 1,999 bids · 17.2 bids per lot
- 242 participants · 126 unique bidders · 153 unique watchlisters
- Total final bids: CAD $5,914.00
- Average sold-lot price: CAD $50.98
Sold for CAD $683 on BidRush
Urban Barn Sectional Sofa — Collingwood, Ontario
Burlington
In Burlington, 279 participants engaged with the auction and 256 lots sold. Featured below is Royal Copenhagen dinnerware that sold for CAD $370.
- 256 of 283 lots sold · 90.5% sell-through
- 2,094 bids · 7.4 bids per lot
- 279 participants · 127 unique bidders · 226 unique watchlisters
- Total final bids: CAD $10,072.25
- Average sold-lot price: CAD $39.34
A note on Burlington’s starting bids: This auction used higher starting bids, which can help explain its lower bids-per-lot figure and the lower sell rate. A higher opening price leaves fewer bidding steps to the final price and can discourage buyers from participating. Think of listing a home at a high asking price: some buyers may pass it over before booking a viewing, reducing the opportunity for competing offers, and often the home goes unsold, sitting on the market until the listing expires, only to be re-listed again and again. BidRush recommends $1 starting bids to encourage participation and give competition room to develop. Starting prices should therefore be considered when comparing bids per lot; these auction totals alone do not establish how much they affected Burlington’s results.
Sold for CAD $370 on BidRush
Royal Copenhagen Blue Fluted Half Lace Dinnerware — Burlington, Ontario
British Columbia: Surrey
Surrey brings the story to British Columbia. This downsizing auction generated 1,268 bids across 80 offered lots, averaging 15.9 bids per lot. Seventy-eight lots sold, with a gold necklace and bracelet achieving CAD $7,300.
- 78 of 80 lots sold · 97.5% sell-through
- 1,268 bids · 15.9 bids per lot
- 87 participants · 48 unique bidders · 66 unique watchlisters
- Total final bids: CAD $17,614.09
- Average sold-lot price: CAD $225.82
Sold for CAD $7,300 on BidRush
Gold Multi-Strand Necklace And Bracelet — Surrey, British Columbia
Washington: Port Ludlow
Port Ludlow attracted 215 unique bidders and 479 participants overall. With 206 of 207 lots sold, it achieved 99.5% sell-through. An electric golf cart led the auction at USD $3,000.
- 206 of 207 lots sold · 99.5% sell-through
- 3,024 bids · 14.6 bids per lot
- 479 participants · 215 unique bidders · 350 unique watchlisters
- Total final bids: USD $13,441.21
- Average sold-lot price: USD $65.25
Sold for USD $3,000 on BidRush
2016 RXV E-Z-GO Electric Golf Cart — Port Ludlow, Washington
Texas: Whitney
In Whitney, 94 unique bidders placed 2,207 bids and 172 lots sold. The leading lot was an assortment of watches and jewelry, which closed at USD $6,650.
- 172 of 174 lots sold · 98.9% sell-through
- 2,207 bids · 12.7 bids per lot
- 159 participants · 94 unique bidders · 103 unique watchlisters
- Total final bids: USD $13,449.80
- Average sold-lot price: USD $78.20
Sold for USD $6,650 on BidRush
Assorted Wristwatches, Pocket Watches and Jewelry — Whitney, Texas
Massachusetts: Carlisle
Finally, Carlisle adds a Massachusetts example. All 165 lots sold, with 135 unique bidders and USD $49,164.25 in total final bids. A gold bracelet was the highest-priced lot at USD $4,650.
- 165 of 165 lots sold · 100% sell-through
- 2,786 bids · 16.9 bids per lot
- 326 participants · 135 unique bidders · 260 unique watchlisters
- Total final bids: USD $49,164.25
- Average sold-lot price: USD $297.97
Sold for USD $4,650 on BidRush
Vintage Yellow Gold 18K Sputnik on 14K Bracelet — Carlisle, Massachusetts
Ask for results you can put in context
These auctions span several communities, different inventories and a wide range of final prices. To evaluate an auction provider, ask for recent completed auctions near you and sold examples that resemble your own items.
- How many unique people bid, and how many participated through bidding or watchlisting?
- How many bids did the auction receive per offered lot?
- What percentage of lots sold?
- What did comparable items sell for, and what would the seller receive after fees?
Planning on Online Auctions? See what you can save in fees here.
See how BidRush is different, and visit BidRush to get started.
About these results
Monetary amounts are in each auction’s original currency: CAD for Canada and USD for the United States. Total sales and highlighted sold prices are final bid amounts before buyer’s premium and taxes.